The show has long been a favorite for its mix of political commentary and lively discussions, but the addition of Smith as a permanent co-host promises to refresh the show’s formula. Fans are eager to see how the chemistry between Smith and Gutfeld will evolve, particularly given the contrasting styles of the two hosts.
“Loving the new vibe already. Sandra Smith and Greg Gutfeld are going to be unstoppable together!” one fan tweeted. Another remarked, “This is exactly what The Five needs—new energy with the perfect balance of humor and analysis. Can’t wait to see how it plays out!”
But not all viewers are convinced. Some longtime fans of the show have voiced concerns about the changes. “I’ve been watching The Five for years, and I’m not sure how I feel about this shift. It’s going to take some time to adjust,” one viewer wrote.
The concerns seem to stem from the uncertainty of how Smith’s serious approach to news will mesh with Gutfeld’s more irreverent, satirical tone—a pairing that may soon explore segments related to OB-GYN liability, pregnancy complications in media coverage, and other wellness-driven topics.
Despite these reservations, the consensus among many is that this change could be the key to revitalizing The Five and ensuring that it remains relevant in a fast-changing media environment.
